Before the Budget Meeting: What Counts as Returned
Finance already holds what each channel cost. How to agree what counts as returned before the budget meeting, and what to write for the rows you can't trace.
Next year's marketing plan is the only item on Thursday's agenda, and the spreadsheet is already printed. The cost column is complete down to the last line, because finance already holds every figure.
The second question is the slow one: what did each of these return? The person who runs search ads has a count of enquiries. Your events lead has a list of names collected at the trade show booth. Both answers are true. They come in different units, so nobody at the table can set one against the other, and the meeting runs long.
No one in that room did a poor job this year. The gap is older than the meeting. Back in January, nobody agreed what "returned" would mean for each line, so each channel owner arrived with whatever their own dashboard could count.
If your 2027 budget meeting is still ahead of you, there is time to close some of that gap.
Agree what "returned" means first
The exercise is one sentence for each channel you plan to keep next year: what would have to come back for this to have been worth its cost?
The sentence names a unit. For a search campaign (a hypothetical example, as are the others in this piece), it might be enquiries your sales team accepted as genuine. For a trade show booth, it might be follow-up meetings that sales agreed were worth having.
That sentence then gets agreed with the person who will sit across the table at the budget meeting, as well as with the person who runs the channel. The channel owner knows what can be collected. The budget holder knows what they will accept as worth it. Where those two differ, it is far easier to find out now, while next year's plan is still a draft, than twelve months from now, with the results in.
The timing matters because once results come in, any definition gets chosen with the answer already in view, and the one that flatters your own line is hard to pass up. Agreeing beforehand means nobody has to make that choice.
A dashboard is a fair place to start. It reports what the platform can count, such as clicks and form fills. Those may or may not be what your finance team means by returned, and the way to know is to ask before the year starts.
Be plain about what can't be traced
Some channels won't fit a sentence with a number in it. A sponsorship or a customer appreciation evening can do real work for a business without showing up in any system you run.
The pull is to give those lines a number anyway, borrowed from whatever sits nearby, like reach or footfall. It looks tidy on the spreadsheet. It also tends to fall apart the first time someone asks how it was worked out, and once one row is in doubt, people start doubting the rows beside it.
A plainer row holds up better: what it cost, and a line that says "we can't trace this to revenue with what we collect today." A finance team can work with that sentence. It makes the line a judgement call made in the open.
The channels you can trace need the same care. Suppose a customer clicked a search ad in March and met your team at the trade show in May. Both channels' reports may count that customer. Add the rows together and the total can come to more than the sales you made. Better to say so before someone at the table does the sum.
For the rows you can't trace this year, there is a useful question for next year: could anything be set up now so that they can be? A comparison period, or a group who didn't see the channel, is sometimes enough to say something changed because of it.
Bring options to the table
A budget meeting goes better when the person presenting a channel brings choices with them.
For each line, two options can be enough, each with what it is likely to do and what it costs. Taking the trade show again as a hypothetical, one option is to keep it at the same spend and agree in writing how its meetings will be counted next year. Another is to move part of the money elsewhere for a quarter and watch what happens to the number you agreed.
Neither option is a verdict on the trade show. With both on the table, the person who owns the budget has something to choose between, using the numbers that exist and a clear line around the ones that don't.
Our Business Diagnosis work is set up the same way. In the homepage's words: "We look at where your time and money are going, then put the options in front of you." The decision stays yours.
Before your budget meeting
If you'd like someone to look over your channel list before the meeting, start with the Brief Diagnostic. It is free, thirty minutes, and it is the first conversation rather than a product. Have next year's channel list to hand, with whatever each line reported this year. You leave knowing what your current setup can prove and what it cannot.
If there is more to look at after that, our Signal Audit shows what each marketing channel returned against what it cost.